There’s No Pilot At The Controls: Why Canadian Citizenship Must Be A Constitutional Right

  • Contributor
  • Canada
  • November 22, 2026

Whether Canadian citizenship is secure is not a departmental processing issue. It is a foundational constitutional question.

By: Don Chapman, Founder The Lost Canadians

In aviation, you’re trained to anticipate every point of failure and build safeguards before an emergency happens. No rational passenger would step onto a plane flown by a crew that never planned for emergencies—yet when it comes to the legal foundation of Canadian citizenship, that is precisely the flight we’re on. There is no pilot at the controls.

Whenever concerns are raised about the fragility of Canadian citizenship law, Ottawa’s reflex is to treat it as an administrative file—routing it to Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) and Minister Lena Metlege Diab. That misses the point entirely. Whether Canadian citizenship is secure is not a departmental processing issue. It is a foundational constitutional question that sits squarely within the mandate of the Minister of Justice and Attorney General, Sean Fraser.

Routing this to IRCC is a dead end. Minister Diab has refused to discuss the issue, and she defended her bureaucrats when they suspended the citizenship of roughly 100 Canadians by email and revoked their passports in June 2026 without due process. Meanwhile, her department still insists Canadian citizenship did not exist prior to January 1, 1947. In aviation terms, the airport is closed.

That refusal has profound consequences for the more than 111,000 soldiers who died fighting for Canada in both world wars. Every Remembrance Day, we tend to graves marked with the maple leaf. Yet according to Ottawa, not one of those fallen soldiers died as a Canadian citizen. The state insists they were merely British subjects—or worse, in the case of Canadian-born Chinese soldiers, stateless “registered aliens.”

Over years of researching citizenship law, I’ve brought an airline captain’s risk-management mindset to our legal framework. The Crown’s position treats citizenship not as an entrenched right, but as a legislated privilege invented by Parliament in 1947.

That premise is a legal fallacy contradicted by Ottawa’s own records. In 1910 the Immigration Act defined Canadian citizenship in statute. The 1921 Canadian Nationals Act declared that every Canadian national was also a Canadian citizen, as defined in the Immigration Act. Additionally, long before 1947, Canada used citizenship as a benchmark for military conscription. In 2013, the Attorney General conceded before the Supreme Court that the Métis were full citizens from 1870 onward. At the 1919 Versailles peace conference, future prime minister Arthur Meighen spoke explicitly “as a Canadian citizen.” During the Second World War, Ottawa issued troops pamphlets titled Canadian Citizenship and the Issues of War, promised war brides automatic citizenship, and listed fallen soldiers as “Canadian citizens” on their death certificates. And when the 1946 Citizenship Act became law, Parliamentarians described it as a codification, not a genesis.

The constitutional stakes are immense. If Canadian citizenship existed before 1947, it is a vested right protected under the British North America Act. If not, citizenship is merely a revocable permission slip managed at the whim of politicians and bureaucrats.

To see why that matters, look south. In November 2016, on the day Donald Trump was elected, my daughter and I protested outside Trump Tower in Vancouver. I warned the crowd that Trump had his finger on the nuclear codes, and expressed hope that Canada would never become to the United States what Poland was to Germany. Having lived in the U.S. and having travelled the world, I knew how quickly democratic institutions can erode.

Fortunately for Americans, the 14th Amendment entrenches birthright citizenship in the U.S. Constitution. Without it, an autocratic government could strip political opponents or journalists of their nationality with the stroke of a pen.

Canada has no 14th Amendment. While the Charter of Rights and Freedoms protects rights that flow from citizenship—such as voting and mobility—it is silent on the right to citizenship itself. By pretending citizenship began in 1947, Ottawa leaves our status dependent on an ordinary statute: the Citizenship Act—which has been and continues to be weaponized.

For nearly a century, courts have had to correct what Parliament refused to. From 1869 to 1985, Indigenous peoples were forced to surrender their Indian status, treaty relationships, and community identity through enfranchisement—in exchange for what the Crown explicitly called “the rights and privileges of Canadian citizenship.” In 1938, the Supreme Court recognized a Chinese-Canadian woman as a “natural-born Canadian citizen” in Shin Shim v. The King. In 1945/46, per orders in council, Ottawa stripped 3,964 Japanese Canadians of their citizenship, then deported them—700 of whom were children born in Canada. When Prime Minister Mackenzie King repealed his order on January 24, 1947, his press release stated it would “restore the Canadian status of persons who have already lost such status.” You cannot restore what never existed.

Yet for 79 years, Ottawa has ignored its own admission. Repeated court battles—from Benner v. Canada in 1997 to Bjorkquist in 2023—were required to patch discriminatory exclusions. It was Sean Fraser, as immigration minister, whose inaction forced us into court over Bjorkquist, and who repeated the outdated claim in 2022 that Canadians were merely British subjects before 1947. Most, but not all, were. And British subject status didn’t go away until 1977. Canadians were both.

Following our parliamentary petition to recognize our war dead as citizens, we’re preparing a federal court challenge to correct the record once and for all. As Minister of Justice, Mr. Fraser should not be the reason families of the fallen and Lost Canadians are forced back into court.

Laws are not built only for fair-weather democracies. Recognizing pre-1947 citizenship honours the more than 111,000 war dead who gave their lives for this country and closes a single point of failure in our constitutional architecture—one that could turn catastrophic if we ever elected a Prime Minister with autocratic tendencies. Canadians are not immune. Before turbulence hits, it’s time for the Minister of Justice to take the yoke.

Don Chapman is the founder of the Lost Canadians and the author of “The Lost Canadians: A Struggle for Citizenship Rights, Equality, and Identity.” 

Summary

The Daily Scrum News