The Dating App Paradox: “I Don’t Need a Man, But Where Are All the Men?”

Image Credit: Sunriseforever

There is a certain type of dating profile that has become almost legendary in the world of online dating. You know the one. The profile proudly announces that she is strong, independent, financially secure, emotionally mature, completely self-sufficient and perfectly capable of doing everything herself. She does not need a man. She can change her own oil, assemble her own furniture, kill her own spiders, open her own pickle jar, pay her own bills, travel alone, buy her own house, fix her own problems and carry her own groceries. She has absolutely no intention of depending on anyone. Then, somewhere near the bottom of the profile, comes the mysterious conclusion: “Looking for a good man to share my life with.” Wait a minute. What exactly is the job description here?

Because after reading the first 700 words, every potential applicant has already been informed that the position is completely unnecessary. This is the great online dating oxymoron: “I don’t need a man, but I would really like one.” There is absolutely nothing wrong with being an independent woman. In fact, independence is attractive. Confidence is attractive. Knowing your worth is attractive. Being financially responsible, emotionally grounded and capable of taking care of yourself is attractive. The problem is not independence. The problem is when independence is presented as a warning label.

Some dating profiles do not say, “I’m a strong woman looking for a strong partner.” They essentially say, “I have survived without a man and will continue to do so indefinitely. If you somehow manage to enter my life, please understand that you are completely unnecessary.” That may be technically accurate, but it is not exactly a compelling recruitment strategy. Imagine walking into a restaurant and the waiter says, “We don’t need your money. We already have money. We don’t need your business. We already have customers. We don’t need you to eat here.” You would probably think, “Well, I guess I’ll go somewhere else.” That is sometimes what happens on dating apps.

Men read these profiles and simply keep scrolling. Not necessarily because they are intimidated by a strong woman. Not necessarily because they want someone dependent. Often, they simply don’t see where they fit. A healthy relationship is not about finding someone who cannot survive without you. It is about finding someone who can survive without you but genuinely wants to build something with you. There is a massive difference between the two. “I don’t need you” and “I don’t need you to complete me, but I want you beside me” are two completely different messages. The first can sound like rejection. The second sounds like partnership.

This is where the oxymoron becomes particularly funny: “I am completely independent, but I am looking for someone to depend on me emotionally, romantically and occasionally financially when the Wi-Fi goes down.” Of course, nobody should pretend to be helpless just to attract a partner. Women should not suddenly write, “I can’t open a jar without assistance,” when they have been doing it themselves for 20 years. Men don’t need to be portrayed as superheroes whose sole purpose is to rescue women from household chores. That is not the point. The point is that dating is about connection.

If your entire profile is dedicated to explaining why you don’t need anybody, you may accidentally convince the people you actually want that there is no room for them. There is another important distinction. There is a difference between saying, “I know what I want and I won’t settle,” and saying, “Every man I’ve ever met has been a disappointment and I’m prepared to explain exactly why.” One sounds confident. The other sounds like a lawsuit waiting to happen. Dating profiles should tell potential partners what you are inviting them into, not simply everything you are trying to keep out.

Instead of writing five paragraphs about what you refuse to tolerate, explain what you appreciate. Instead of listing every terrible experience you’ve had with men, describe the kind of relationship you want. Instead of saying, “I don’t need a man,” try saying, “I’ve built a good life for myself, and I’d love to share it with someone who has built a good life of his own.” That is still strong. That is still independent. That is still confident. It just doesn’t sound like you’re interviewing him for the position of “Person Who Will Be Constantly Reminded That He Is Not Necessary.”

There is nothing wrong with needing someone occasionally. There is also nothing wrong with wanting someone when you don’t need them. That may actually be one of the healthiest reasons to enter a relationship. You are not together because one person cannot function without the other. You are together because life is better when you function together. A woman can be perfectly capable of carrying her own groceries and still appreciate a man who carries them sometimes. She can pay her own mortgage and still enjoy having someone beside her at the end of a long day. She can solve her own problems and still want a partner with whom she can share the victories, frustrations, laughter and ordinary moments of life.

So, ladies, by all means, keep your independence. Keep your career. Keep your money. Keep your apartment. Keep changing your own tires. Keep killing your own spiders. Keep being the woman who knows her worth. Just remember that there is a difference between demonstrating that you are capable of standing alone and making someone wonder why you are inviting them to stand beside you.

Because when your dating profile screams, “I don’t need a man,” and then whispers, “So why isn’t anyone dating me?”, the answer may be sitting right there in the profile. The modern dating oxymoron isn’t that independent women want relationships. It is this: “I don’t need you. I just want you. And if you’re lucky, I’ll let you matter.” That is a much better message than making every potential partner feel like an unnecessary accessory to a life that is already completely occupied.

Dating is not about finding someone you cannot live without. It is about finding someone you would genuinely like to live with. There is a difference between dependency and desire, between weakness and vulnerability, and between needing someone and choosing someone. The strongest relationship may actually be the one where two people are perfectly capable of standing on their own but decide that standing together is better.

So perhaps the best dating-app advice is simple: Don’t advertise yourself as unavailable and then complain that nobody is applying. If you want a man, leave some room for a man. You don’t have to surrender your independence to make room for companionship. You simply have to stop making your potential partner feel like he is applying for a job that your profile spent 500 words convincing him does not exist.